Basement suite or garage suite: which one?
Since the City of Calgary repealed citywide rezoning (in effect 4 August 2026), a property can have either a secondary (basement) suite or a backyard suite, not both. A basement suite usually costs far less because the house already exists. A garage suite costs more but gives a fully separate home and a new garage. Peak builds both, so we can tell you honestly which fits.

Side by side
| Basement suite | Garage suite | |
|---|---|---|
| Which homes | Single-detached and semi-detached homes; rowhouses and townhouses too | Single-detached homes only (semi-detached no longer qualify) |
| City approval | A permitted use in all low-density districts (Council decision, July 2026) | A discretionary use in most districts (permitted in R-G), with a 21-day appeal period |
| Cost | Usually far less: the foundation, structure and services already exist | $200,000 to $350,000 with us, including a new garage |
| Privacy | Shares walls, floors and often noise with the house | A separate building with its own door and yard |
| Light and ceiling height | Limited by the basement's windows and height | Windows on every side, full ceiling height |
| Parking | Depends on the property | A parking stall is required, and the garage below adds more |
| During the build | Work happens inside your house | Work happens in the backyard and the lane |
When a basement suite makes more sense
- The budget is well under $200,000.
- The home is semi-detached, a rowhouse or a townhouse.
- The basement already has good height, windows and a separate entrance, or can get them.
When a garage suite makes more sense
- You want the most privacy for both households.
- You need a new garage anyway.
- You want to keep the basement for your own family.
- The lot has a back lane and room for the suite and a parking stall.
Already have a basement suite?
Then the property can't also have a backyard suite under the current rules. Talk to us before you design anything: we'll check how your existing suite is registered and what your options are.
One company for both
Peak Garage Suite is part of Peak Basement Renovations, which builds legal basement suites. You get one honest answer about which suite fits your lot, not a sales pitch for the only thing we build.
Sources: City of Calgary, Repeal of citywide rezoning, Building a backyard suite and Suites permit costs and timelines (checked 16 November 2026).
Get a free lot check and quote
Send your address and a few details. We'll tell you what your lot allows and what it would cost, within 2 business days.